**20**wrote:

Dear Bioconductor,

I have a fluidigm (or other array) experiment which consists of 4 groups: A, B, C, and D.

The experimentalist I am helping wants to compare B to A and D to C,

but not B to D or B to C, etc.

Do I

1. Run all 4 groups together in Limma and then analyze the individual contrasts

OR

2. do I compare B to A and D to C in 2 separate Limma runs?

I believe that 1 is correct, because in an ANOVA one should take into account

the variability of all of the samples, Furthermore, as I understand Limma, more

samples improves the empirical Bayesian estimate of the variance. However, this

approach has recently been questioned by 3 different experimental collaborators,

from 3 different labs, in 3 different contexts, so, I think that it would be prudent to ask the list.

Thanks and best wishes,

Rich

Richard Friedman

**560**• written 18 months ago by raf4 •

**20**