Question: Genome editing analysis with Illumina sequencing
gravatar for Merienne Nicolas
4.6 years ago by
Merienne Nicolas120 wrote:

Dear all,

I have a very large and open question concerning the methods to analyse genome editing experiments with sequencing. I am using the CRISPR system to create indels at precise locations in the genome and I am interesting to determine the efficiency of gene disruption by determining the percentage of reads containing indels. I am planning to amplify by PCR the target region and then to use paired-end sequencing with the MiSeq system. Before doing the experiment, I looked for the different published methods to count the number of reads with indels and I found a lot of different ways to obtain this result. And now I would say that it is confusing for me which method could be better than the other ones ("the paradox of choice"...). So, does anyone know if there is a validated method for indels quantifications?

In particular, I found papers using Bowtie/BWA alignment but also some of them rather use Smith-Waterman algorithm. Is there a prefered method for indel quantification? I found that BWA-MEM is efficient for variant analysis and compatible with longer read length (300-600bp for MiSeq), is it really the case?

Then, there are various methods to count the number of reads containing indels. I found mainly methods determining the percent of NHEJ based on the number of reads that could be aligned to the reference amplicon sequence in 2 blocks, other ones using GATK for whole genome sequencing in such experiments and another one estimating the probability that a read carries a real indel based on the mean quality score of each read (I think this is the quality score of aligment resulting from Smith-Waterman algorithm, but I am not sure). Is there an efficient and correct method already known for this quantification? Is it possible to use GATK for such analysis on PCR products?

I hope my explanations are sufficiently clear. Thank you very much for your help.



sequencing alignment indel • 716 views
ADD COMMENTlink written 4.6 years ago by Merienne Nicolas120
Please log in to add an answer.


Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy.
Powered by Biostar version 16.09
Traffic: 463 users visited in the last hour