FDR via q-value
Entering edit mode
John • 0
Last seen 4 weeks ago

Hi everyone,

So I am a little confused with the application of q-values or more broadly, FDR correction (BH or BKY).

I have run multiple linear mixed effect models to assess the impact of medication on several brain regions and have a total of 245 p-values in a matrix.

Do I apply the q-value method to the entire matrix of q-values? or should I apply it by region? (lets say there are appox 30 p-values for each region)

Likewise, If i was to use the BH or BKY FDR correction method, would I apply this to the entire matrix or by region?

If i do decide to go with the q-value approach, do I have enough p-values to produce robust q-values?

Finally, which method is more robust overall? I dont want to be overly conservative but I also want to adequately control for type-1 errors.

Note, there is no problem with my r code, I understand how to apply each FDR procedure, I'm just finding it difficult to find oncrete infromation on whether to apply to the entire model (which I would likely do with the q-value approach considering it will likely underperform with such low amounts of p-values by region) or by region?

Any advice would be greatly appeciated!

qvalue • 145 views
Entering edit mode
Last seen 5 hours ago
United States

General analysis questions like this are off-topic for this site. You might try over on biostars.org or stackoverflow.com

Login before adding your answer.

Traffic: 504 users visited in the last hour
Help About
Access RSS

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy.

Powered by the version 2.3.6